Sign up for NEW free healthy recipes - Currently over 300,000 subscribers!

I Scream, You Scream, We All Scream…

Pin It!

For our very first date, Mr. Vitamix 5200 and I decided to go out for ice cream. Except, thanks to Mr. Vitamix, we didn’t have to “go out” at all!

While browsing through the Vitamix cookbook (it comes with the blender), my eye caught a recipe for vitamix soft serve ice cream.  It looked so easy– the only ingredients are milk, sweetener, and ice!  I put mine over a few slices of banana and some chocolate syrup, of course.


I thought it tasted good… until Vitamix and I went out for another date and met up with this handsome fellow:

Hello Peanut Butter and Banana Ice Cream!

As an experiment, I blended together some peanut butter, banana slices, and almond milk. Then I poured the soupy mixture into a bowl and froze it overnight. The next day, I re-blended it, and the result was a creamy, delicious, and wholly-healthy homemade ice cream.

(Edit: If you omit the milk and just use frozen banana with Banana Butter, there’s no need to re-blend.)

Sidenote: Mr. Food Processor would like to thank everyone who expressed concerns about his well-being. Rest assured that he is doing fine. In fact, my blogger friend, Cody, informed me that he’s recently struck up a rebound relationship with her toaster. But I am still open to the prospect of a future one-night-stand every now and then with Mr. FP (to chop carrots, make bread crumbs, or for another small job). So he is actually not completely out of my life.

For tips and tricks, see: How to make Vitamix Ice Cream.

Rate this recipe

Katie is the baker, photographer, and author of the popular blog Chocolate-Covered Katie. Her favorite food is chocolate, and she believes in eating a balanced diet that includes dessert every single day. More about Katie—> 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Healthy eating blog says: that sounds amazing! nice and cool sounds great considering i have an unknown sickness right not that has me running a fever 101.9-102.6

  2. romina says:

    You should open an ice cream shop!!!

  3. loveofoats says:

    Wow – delicious 🙂 I think I might try this w/ my boring old blender and see if it’s as good as Mr. Vitamix!

  4. talieworld says:

    I agree with romina.They look so good!

  5. Caitlin says:

    Yum! I think I should try making ice cream…my parents have a 15-year-old Vitamix I could use–it’s starting to show its age a little, but I think it still works pretty well. BTW, I don’t know if you’ve ever had this before, but I found an amazing (and simple!) recipe for chocolate (soy)milk shakes from the Joy of Vegan Baking: 1 cup soymilk, 1 frozen banana, 2 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder. It’s really good and soooo creamy! They also say you can add 1 or 2 teaspoons of sugar if you want, but I never do…I like it kind of bittersweet! 🙂 Any recommendations on ice cream making? Is it best to freeze your ingredients first (other than the milk, obviously)?

  6. Cherry says:

    Looks great, I wish I had a vitamix!

  7. Jill says:

    Holy….. I need one of these things. Well no, I don’t, I’ve spent fair too much money on kitchen gadgets!

  8. shellyfish says:

    You are too darn cute Ms. Mixalot! I hope Santa brings me a vitamix for christmas…

  9. Jenn says:

    What a success!! I used to love getting Reese’s peanut butter cup blizzards at Dairy Queen. Haven’t had one for a while…but now that I know what’s possible with the Vitamix, I guess I don’t need to spend the moola!! YUM!

  10. Anonymous says:

    Omigosh! That looks so good!

    How much milk, sugar and ice did you use?

    Do you think this could this been done in a regular blender. I am not familiar with what vitamixes are. Is it just freezing the milk, ice and sugar and then putting it in the blender. Are there other steps that I’m missing?

  11. Kelly T says:

    thats the healthiest ice cream ever. i have a huge ice cream addiction so i might have to invest in one of those and make some flavors of my own.

    ill have to keep it a secret cause my boyfriend would get mad if he knew i was cheating with appliances

  12. lighterportions says:

    Mmm homemade banana pb ice cream sounds absolutely perfect. and so easy!

  13. Jennifer says:

    I thought Mr. Vitamix had me with the first ice cream, but peanut butter banana? Watch out Katie, I may have to try to steal Mr. Vitamix’s heart. 😉

  14. Ricki says:

    Those both look perfect for the hot evening we’re having here! I”m wondering if my poor weak Osterizer will be able to do the same job. . .

    Looking forward to your prom nostalgia!

  15. Vegan On Stage says:

    WHERE DID YOU GET THIS THING!!!!!! I think Im going to be buying it in the near future!!!!! Do you think this ice cream would work with a regular blender???? Whats the difference??

  16. vegan addict says:

    Oh…sigh…you make me laugh! Relationships with kitchen appliances are very essential to our well-being. I used to ummmm…kiss my Kitchen Aid stand mixer when I first got it. But seriously, don’t go telling people that! The strawberry/chocolate almond milk concoction has me wishing those ingredients were in my kitchen.

  17. choc_puddin says:

    i totally drooled just then.
    Dammit now I have an insatiable craving for ice cream

    So one night stand huh? Don’t you go instigating a little boo-tay just to break ole food processor’s heart now. Be very clean about your intentions

  18. Amanda says:

    What are you favorite smoothie combinations? You seem to be the smoothie pro!

  19. Healthy eating blog says:

    no way! i was reading some of your earlier posts and found out you live in texas……..well………………….SO DO I! 🙂 how cool is that!? have you ever been to the grocery store sprouts?

  20. Cody says:

    Yummy… peanut butter and banana sounds awesome.

    And, yes. Kitchen appliances make for great relationships. I often pet Mixey the stand mixer and tell him I love him. (He’s just so orange and pretty.)

Want To Get Healthier?

Opt in to receive new FREE healthy recipes each week - delivered straight to your inbox!