This is my new favorite roasted butternut squash recipe – hopefully you will love it too!
Doing something a little bit different today!
I’ve been getting a lot of requests to publish more What I Eat In A Day style posts, and yet I also know some readers are more interested in just the recipes. So today’s post includes both meals and recipes.
After three Friendsgivings, a family dinner, and eating Thanksgiving leftovers for the past four days straight, I think it’s safe to say I’ve consumed more than my fair share of Thanksgiving foods for the rest of the year.
Above is my plate from Thursday’s family dinner (minus the gravy, the desserts, and the wine). Our family tradition didn’t change much when I gave up meat over ten years ago – I just eat the sides and not the turkey, which was pretty much what I did even as a child, because turkey was never my favorite… I always saw it as wasting prime space that could have been filled with more marshmallow sweet potatoes!
Sometimes I’ll make a vegan main dish, and I did also do the Tofurky thing once, which is kind of a rite of passage for every vegetarian. But this year there were more than enough sides to turn into a delicious feast, leaving me plenty of time to work on perfecting my homemade pecan pie.
Dessert was Healthy Pumpkin Pie, coconut whipped cream (Whole Foods and Trader Joes both now sell canned coconut whipped cream!), and the aforementioned homemade pecan pie. I’m currently trying to decide if I should post the pecan pie recipe this year in time for Christmas or save it until Thanksgiving comes around again next year.
I know the canned cranberry jelly on my plate is not the healthiest food in the world by any stretch of the imagination, but I always have to take a little when it’s offered, more for the nostalgia aspect than anything else.
Marshmallow Sweet Potatoes:
Simply use the method outlined in my post on How To Cook Sweet Potatoes, then either melt vegan marshmallows on top or cover the sweet potatoes with Healthy Vegan Marshmallow Fluff. The higher-oven cooking technique gets the sweet potatoes so caramelized and sweet that there’s really no need to add any extra sugar!
Caramelized Onions:
I like to caramelize my onions in the oven, because it’s ridiculously easy. The most difficult part is slicing the onions without crying, which I’ve never been able to do. Spread the sliced onions in a parchment-lined glass baking dish and place in a cold oven. You can do the sweet potatoes at the same time to save energy. Turn the oven to 480 F and let it preheat with the onions already in the oven. Mine are nice and caramelized after a half hour or so, and then I season them with a little salt and sometimes some oil or buttery spread (which you can omit if desired).
Roasted Butternut Squash:
The cinnamon roasted butternut squash recipe was something new this year that I dreamed up while roasting a container of pre-cut butternut squash from Trader Joe’s a few weeks ago. Basically, I just combined a bunch of ingredients I thought sounded like they’d be good together—sliced apples, cinnamon, raisins, pure maple syrup, and the butternut squash. The results were just as fantastic as I’d imagined, and this will be a staple at the Thanksgiving (and most likely Christmas) table from now on.
I’ve written the recipe out further down in this post, and feel free to substitute what you have on hand. Dried cranberries can be subbed for the raisins, shredded coconut or crushed walnuts can be added, and if you want to use sweet potatoes instead of butternut squash, that works too!
If you want to cut your own butternut squash, I’d recommend peeling it first before chopping. Butternut squash is one of only two vegetables that I buy pre-cut whenever possible, because the time and effort saved is well worth the extra money spent.
(The other vegetable I buy pre-cut is onions. Cutting onions is my least favorite cooking task by far.)
Roasted Butternut Squash
Roasted Butternut Squash Recipe
Ingredients
- 5 cups peeled, cubed butternut squash OR sweet potatoes
- 2 cups diced apple
- 1/2 cup raisins or dried cranberries
- 2 tsp cinnamon
- 1/2 tsp salt
- sweetener of choice, such as 2 tbsp pure maple syrup or pinch stevia
- optional 1 tbsp oil or buttery spread, for richness
Instructions
Stir all of the ingredients together (minus the sweetener if using a liquid sweetener). Spread out in one large baking dish, or two medium baking dishes, lined with parchment paper. Place on the center rack of an unheated oven, then turn to 480 F. Bake 40 minutes. Stir, return to the oven, and close the door. Turn off the heat but leave in the closed oven an additional 10 minutes. Stir in the sweetener, if using a liquid. Good hot or cold, and leftovers can be refrigerated 3-4 days or even frozen if desired.
Links Of The Day:
Flourless Pancakes – 3 Ingredients
Nicole @ Bento Momentos says
My favorite thing on your plate would be the butternut squash. Yum!! We had a non-traditional Thanksgiving of ham, eggrolls, flautas, noodles, and carrot cake. It was delicious. 🙂
Chocolate Covered Katie says
That sounds even better. I think carrot cake is way better than pumpkin pie 🙂
Whitney says
OMG I love you Black dress where is it from?
Whitney says
your*
Chocolate Covered Katie says
Urban Outfitters!
Olivia says
Hi! I’m been reading your blog since 2012, when I was twelve. I think I’ve only ever commented on one other post but I just wanted to say thank you. I found it since I used to have a lot of food allergies, including dairy and milk, and your blog had so many dessert options. I outgrew these allergies and started high school and stuff, and I wasn’t checking back for new posts quite as much over the past few years, but I’m seventeen now and I’ve been obsessed again recently. Love all the “what I eat in a day” posts! And please post the pecan pie for Christmas…I can’t wait until next year haha. Please never stop!
Chocolate Covered Katie says
Aw this completely made my night. Thank you 🙂
Emily says
Yum! This is making me miss Thanksgiving already. 🙂 I am with you and would totally go the pre-chopped butternut squash route. 🙂
xo,
Em
Michelle says
Thanks for showing such a healthy approach to food and also that being healthy can totally mean choosing unhealthy indulgences every now and then and not stressing about it. Reading your blog has helped me so much with my eating issues and helped me to have a much better relationship with food.
Also you are absolutely gorgeous!
Chocolate Covered Katie says
Thank you!
anonymous says
Anorexic.
JJ says
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
Sssssss says
no she’s too fat to be anorexic lololol
Natasha says
Katie is a beautiful girl, and she isn’t fat. She’s in great shape. Find something else to waste your time on- especially since your trolling is based on lies, aha.
JJ says
These posts are so helpful, thank you!!
Lisa says
OMG! Pecan pie recipe, pleeeeeeeease!
Mark Guncheon says
Katie, who is in the picture with you?
And thanks for posting. So much good food!
Vanessa says
It’s her sister https://chocolatecoveredkatie.com/2007/10/26/more-of-boston/
Kelli says
My son and I cooked a fabulous vegan feast. I made a holiday lentil loaf that was delicious and all the fixings with a blackberry pie to top it off (my son’s fave)
Chocolate Covered Katie says
That all looks seriously amazing!
Johanna Hiller says
You show stuffing in the photo of your T-Day meal. What is the recipe?
Chocolate Covered Katie says
That part was actually not made by me. It’s my mom’s 🙂
Missa says
Katie, you CANNOT withhold the pecan pie until next year XD As a vegan, you’re against needless suffering to living things, right? D; hehe 🙂
In other words, pretty please? ♡
Also love your Thanksgiving plate. Delicious, and nutritious the best combo 😀 And all the colors look gorgeous.
Chocolate Covered Katie says
I will try to get it posted! There are so many Christmas cookies I want to post, but hopefully I can fit everything in.
Km says
Katie – I’ve loved your website and many of your recipes for years and tell people about it all the time. I assume you don’t like cutting onions due to the burning eyes so I thought I’d share a tip with you. After you make the first cut simply run it under cold water for 30-60 seconds. No more burning eyes!
Chocolate Covered Katie says
Absolutely going to try this. Thank you! 🙂
Cassie Autumn Tran says
What a perfect Thanksgiving meal! Yes, marshmallow sweet potatoes would probably comprise of 75% of my plate. LOL! But in all seriousness, sweet potatoes and any butternut squash or Brussels sprouts dishes are my favorites! The roasted butternut squash recipe looks perfect. The raisins add such beautiful colors to it!
Lizzy Amirana says
HOW DID YOU MAKE THE STUFFING?!?!?! its my favorite part about thanksgiving! I almost cried when i saw my aunt take the only stuffing out of the poor Turkeys butt hole… I mean I guess that leads to more room for pie and wine, right?;)
Chocolate Covered Katie says
It’s my mom’s recipe, so I will have to ask her. And yes, one should always make sure there is enough room for pie and wine 😉
Emily says
Your Thanksgiving meal looks amazing! :^)
This is my first time I’ve commented on your blog but I just wanted to say thank you for sharing all these fantastic recipes, I’m really grateful for your time and dedication to write such fun blogs! You have no idea how many times I’ve successfully made your recipes these past months, I love them all! Here’s a picture of my attempts of your cornbread and chocolate pecan pie recipes! (My family loved them!)
Chocolate Covered Katie says
I love your picture so much and am so honored you tried the recipes!
Michael says
Even easier solution to onion eyes: Slip on a pair of swim goggles! Boom! Gone!
Nina says
Love this post. Everything looks so yummy. You and your sister look beautiful.
Janine says
What a wonderful idea to Show a selection of your Food for TG lovely. Nice picture from both of you btw. xoxo Janine
Chocolate Covered Katie says
Aw happy Thanksgiving, Janine!
Cait says
Now I’m hungry….
Also, the chef at my restaurant says that the sharper your knife is, the less likely onions will be to make you cry. 🙂 The blunter the knife has gotten, the less likely it can slice through cleanly, which will send more particles up into the air… and your eyes.
Jason Sanford says
That’s so interesting. I’m going to try it!
-Jason
Jeannette says
Three things:
1. the fact that you included your cranberry sauce slice makes me SO HAPPY!! i always feel like the outlier because it just isn’t thanksgiving without it!! but most people hate it!
2. your sister/friend/cousin/pretty person next to you’s dress is SO BEAUTIFUL and i think i need it.
3. you are beautiful! in case no one told you today!
rock on!
Lee Anne says
Hi Katie..I have been following your blog for many years and love your recipes. I think I remember that years ago you posted a hot pumpkin drink in a mug that I loved. But now I can’t find the recipe. (I hope it was your blog, if not, sorry!)
Is it possible to re-post it? It is soooo good!
Thank you.
Jason Sanford says
https://chocolatecoveredkatie.com/2011/09/08/pumpkin-spice-latte-for-one/
lollo says
I don’t know what happened with my recipe, but the raisins ended up burned rock hard. I followed the instructions, with the only differences being that I used aluminum foil and only baked the dish for about 30 minutes, since it started to smelled burned.
Jason Sanford says
Hi, hmmm maybe that aluminum conducts heat so it cooked faster? Did you preheat the oven or put it into a cold oven?